Commentary by Jack Mirkinson, in The Multiplural World, May 6, 2024
Decisions to sick the police on peaceful protesters at university campuses across the U.S. is evidence that the people in charge are panicking. They’re terrified of the strength of the movement for Palestine.
[Jack Mirkinson is a senior editor at The Nation. This commentary was first published in The Nation on Wednesday, May 1. Read also: The mainstream media distorted our anti-Vietnam War protests 50 years ago. They’re following the same strategy today, media analysis by James North, in Mondoweiss, May 5, 2024.]
Columbia University finds itself at the center of a global movement after students launched a Gaza Solidarity Encampment in late April 2024. On the night of April 30, Columbia president Minouche Shafik apparently decided that the protests could no longer be tolerated and called in the New York Police Department to “maintain order” and ensure that no more tents pop up on the West Lawn. The NYPD happily complied.
Officers forced their way into Hamilton Hall, which had been occupied by protesters, and violently cleared the building. Dozens of people were arrested. Further uptown, police ran riot at the City College of New York, where another student encampment and occupation had sprung up. Hundreds of officers stormed the school, violently arrested protesters, and hauled dozens of people away. After the campus had been cleared, police raised the American flag.
New York City Council member Chi Ossé summed the scene up well, tweeting, “Tonight in the United States of America, we are witnessing a militarized police force, funded by NYC taxpayers, arresting American students in the name of a foreign country that’s carrying out a genocide.”
In Los Angeles, police stood by and watched as a group of Israel supporters beat pro-Palestinian demonstrators at UCLA during the overnight of April 30/May 1, attacking them with mace and fireworks. Police also used pepper spray on students at the University of South Florida earlier on Tuesday, April 30.
While all of this was happening, Israel continued bombing Palestinians up and down the Gaza Strip.
The ‘shock-and-awe campaign’ in the U.S. was about smashing a rapidly expanding student movement whose bravery has captivated people around the world. It was about eliminating the threat that the pro-Palestine movement poses to business as usual. It was about showing university donors, Republicans, Democrats, and the White House that these schools knew which side they were supposed to be on.
And it was about reminding these students—these kids who had the nerve to sit in tents—of who is in charge and who isn’t. The students at Columbia and City College and UCLA and the University of South Florida and all of the more than 70 Gaza solidarity protests that have emerged at campuses around the country committed the sin of believing that it is acceptable for them to try to influence what happens at their school or—heaven forbid—what happens in the world at large. The hope is that these protesters will learn who the world is really supposed to work for—that there is a sky-high price to be paid for questioning the natural order of things. You can feel the question thrumming through the violence and repression: How dare you?
But here’s the lesson in all this: The people in charge are scared. They are terrified of the power of the movement for Palestine—of its size, moral righteousness, fearlessness, diversity, and love. And they are terrified that one of the key pillars of the American system—support for Israel no matter what it does—is being shaken.
Administrators and politicians are panicking. People aren’t supposed to question the billions of dollars we send to Israel or the nature of Israel’s apartheid system. They’re supposed to think that Zionism is sacred and that no Jew could ever oppose it. They’re supposed to stand by and watch as Israel commits crimes against humanity. But instead, they are rising up. There are more encampments every day.
The past seven months in Palestine have been horrendous. The atrocities Israel has committed are almost too much to wrap your mind around, and U.S. government complicity is almost too much to bear. But if we have seen the worst of what the world has to offer, we have also seen the best. The movement for Palestinian liberation is stronger than ever. People are putting their futures and their lives on the line for Palestine, in numbers we’ve never seen. There has been a collective awakening. Nobody knows what that awakening will lead to, but it feels clear that on some fundamental level, it can’t go back to the status quo.
The statements from the likes of the White House, New York City Mayor Eric Adams and Columbia’s president Minouche Shafik amount to spitting at the students. ‘How dare you?’, they are saying.
Students all over the country know the answer to that question, and so does everyone else fighting for Palestinian liberation. The students are ‘daring’ to act as they are because that is how the world changes. And make no mistake, the world is changing now. All the cops in the world can’t stop that.
